The Inside Story: A Free Press Matters
Episode 160 – September 5, 2024
Show Open:
This week on The Inside Story…
We’re two months from the U.S. presidential election.
Worldwide political disinformation is on the rise
And advances in artificial intelligence make it harder to spot.
Now… on The Inside Story: Usa Votes 2024: A Free Press Matters.
The Inside Story:
JESSICA JERREAT, VOA Press Freedom Editor:
Hello, I’m Jessica Jerreat, VOA Press Freedom Editor. Welcome to the Inside Story: A Free Press Matters.
With the U.S. presidential elections less than — two – months–away, efforts to influence the outcome – and disinformation — are on the rise.
We take a look at those issues later. But first, Scott Stearns gets us started.
((PLAYBOOK SLUG: E24 0904 TRUMP HARRIS TWO MONTHS TO GO
HEADLINE: Trump, Harris campaign on economy, prepare for debate
TEASER: Just over 2 months to go before U.S. presidential election
PUBLISHED AT: (9/3/24 & TIME)
BYLINE: Scott Stearns
CONTRIBUTOR:
DATELINE: Denver
VIDEOGRAPHER:
VIDEO EDITOR:
ASSIGNING EDITOR: Bush
SCRIPT EDITORS: Reifenrath, Baragona
VIDEO SOURCE (S): AP, REUTERS
PLATFORMS (mark with X): WEB __ TV _X_ RADIO _X_
TRT:
VID APPROVED BY:
TYPE: TVR
EDITOR NOTES:))
((INTRO)) With just over two months to go before Election Day in the United States, presidential nominees Donald Trump and Kamala Harris are preparing for their first debate and campaigning on the economy. VOA correspondent Scott Stearns looks at the state of the race.
((AP Video ID: 4514934))
5. Various of Trump greeting rally audience
((NARRATOR))
Donald Trump is campaigning hard on the economy and on Kamala Harris.
3. SOUNDBITE (English) Donald Trump, former U.S. President:
((Donald Trump, Republican Presidential Nominee))
“Here’s what we know about comrade Kamala Harris. She just doesn’t care about the American people, especially hard-working people or middle-class Americans. She just doesn’t give a damn about you.”
((Harris Campaign Video))
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pjTjb63DgY8
((NARRATOR)) ((Courtesy: YouTube bug + @kamalaharris))
The Harris campaign says it’s Trump who will hurt working families with tax cuts for corporations.
((Harris at 00:10 of campaign commercial))
((Kamala Harris, Democratic Presidential Nominee))
“Building up the middle class will be a defining goal of my presidency.”
((NATS Commercial Narrator))
“She’ll make groceries more affordable by cracking down on price gouging. And she’ll cut housing costs by taking on corporate speculators.”))
((REUTERS USN: RW019129082024RP1))
30. VARIOUS OF TRUMP SUPPORTERS SITTING IN THE AUDIENCE
((NARRATOR))
The economy is voters’ top issue in this election. That is a problem Harris needs to fix quickly, says political consultant Hank Sheinkopf.
33. (SOUNDBITE) (English) POLITICAL CONSULTANT AND PRESIDENT OF SHEINKOPF COMMUNICATIONS, DR. HANK SHEINKOPF, SAYING:
((Hank Sheinkopf, Political Consultant))
“She’s got to explain why people are paying what they think is more at the gas pump and why their bread costs as much as it does, and why the manufacturers of those products are giving them less for their dollar.”
((AP Video ID: 4514679))
1. Pan, Republican Vice Presidential nominee JD Vance, kisses wife Usha, and walks onto stage
((NARRATOR))
Trump running mate JD Vance says voting for Harris means losing more U.S. jobs.
4. SOUNDBITE (English) JD Vance, Republican Vice Presidential nominee:
((JD Vance, Republican Vice Presidential Nominee))
“Think of all the powerful interests, the broken bureaucracy in this country, the people who’ve gotten rich shipping your jobs to China. They want Kamala Harris. The only way to beat them and the only way to fight back is at the ballot box this November.”
((REUTERS USN: RW991028082024RP1))
1. DEMOCRATIC VICE PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE TIM WALZ BEING INTRODUCED ON STAGE, WALZ APPROACHING MIC
((NARRATOR))
Harris’s running mate, Tim Walz, says it is Democrats who are committed to U.S. workers.
7. (SOUNDBITE) (English) DEMOCRATIC VICE PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE TIM WALZ SAYING:
((Tim Walz, Democratic Vice Presidential Nominee))
“Donald Trump and JD Vance, they have something a little different in mind. The only thing these guys know about working people is how to take advantage of them, how to not pay them. Every single chance they’ve gotten, they’ve waged a war on workers and the ability to collectively bargain.”
((REUTERS USN: RW021329082024RP1))
2. VARIOUS OF PEOPLE WAITING TO ENTER FORMER U.S. PRESIDENT AND CURRENT REPUBLICAN PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE DONALD TRUMP’S RALLY AT ALRO STEEL PLANT
((NARRATOR))
With just over two months to go, this is a close race. Most public opinion polls show Harris with a slight lead over Trump nationally. Michigan voter David Martinez backs Trump.
7. (SOUNDBITE) (English) DAVID MARTINEZ, RESIDENT OF MUSKEGON, MICHIGAN, SAYING:
((David Martinez, Michigan Voter))
“He’s a true American patriot. I think that he thinks more about people that live in this country than he does [of] himself. Everything that he does is to try to help somebody.”
((REUTERS USN: RW032429082024RP1))
11. VARIOUS OF CROWD CHEERING
((NARRATOR))
Georgia voter Becca Rush backs Harris.
12. (SOUNDBITE) (English) SAVANNAH RESIDENT, BECCA RUSH, 57, SAYING:
((Becca Rush, Georgia Voter))
“You know, it’s 2024, we need some fresh blood, and we need a new brighter future.”
((SPLIT SCREEN
REUTERS USN: RW032129082024RP1
4. (SOUNDBITE) (English) REPUBLICAN PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE AND FORMER U.S. PRESIDENT, DONALD J. TRUMP, SAYING:
PLUS
REUTERS USN: RW106302092024RP1
2. HARRIS SPEAKING AT LECTERN))
((NARRATOR))
While continuing to campaign, Trump and Harris will spend much of the next week preparing for their first presidential debate September 10.
((Scott Stearns, VOA News))
JESSICA JERREAT:
With the U.S. Presidential election drawing close, analysts are seeing an increase of foreign efforts to disrupt the outcome. They say information manipulation, political violence… and intimidation are on the rise. Here’s Veronica Balderas Iglesias.
((PLAYBOOK SLUG: E24 0816 Freedom House-US Election
HEADLINE: Domestic, Foreign efforts to disrupt U.S. presidential election are up: researchers
TEASER:
PUBLISHED AT: 08/15/2024 at 8:10am
BYLINE: Veronica Balderas Iglesias
CONTRIBUTOR:
DATELINE: Washington
VIDEOGRAPHER:
VIDEO EDITOR: Veronica Balderas Iglesias
SCRIPT EDITORS: Baragona, MAS, djones approved
VIDEO SOURCE (S): Agencies, Skype, see script for others
PLATFORMS (mark with X): WEB __ TV _X_ RADIO __
TRT: 2:43
VID APPROVED BY: Bill Ide
TYPE: TVR
EDITOR NOTES:((Radio Tracks for Reversioning Included. Agencies’ logos that look lighter or different were burnt by the source. EDITOR NOTES: ((Radio Tracks for Reversioning Included. Agencies’ logos that look lighter or different were burnt by the source. Skype interviews in the corresponding folder in my Frame io. In Progress folder Vero Balderas ))
((TV INTRO))
[[Two reports released this week sound the alarm about an increase in efforts to disrupt the U.S. presidential election. They say information manipulation, political violence and intimidation are on the rise. VOA’s Veronica Balderas Iglesias reports.]]
((NARRATOR))
U.S. voters are increasingly being targeted by domestic actors who spread false information ahead of the 2024 presidential election. That’s according to an election vulnerabilities report by the human-rights group Freedom House.
[[RADIO INTRO: Kian Vesteinsson is the organization’s Senior Research Analyst. He spoke via Skype]]
((Kian Vesteinsson, Freedom House)) – ((Skype))
“People here in the United States who are percolating conspiracy theories and misleading information about politics. Some 70% of Republicans and Republican leaning voters have been captured by the conspiracy theory that the results of the 2020 presidential election were illegitimate. Now, ahead of 2024 we’ve seen that narrative already emerging and dominant.”
((NARRATOR))
There’s also a rise in online intimidation and harassment of election officials as well as political violence, the researcher notes.
((Kian Vesteinsson, Freedom House)) – ((Skype))
“We’ve seen political candidates experiencing direct attacks, including, of course, the assassination attempt against former President Trump, hate speech and hate crimes against marginalized groups are on the rise.”
((NARRATOR))
While the voting infrastructure itself remains protected, cyberattacks are a source of concern, Vesteinsson says.
((Kian Vesteinsson, Freedom House)) – ((Skype))
“The most vulnerable targets are campaigns and websites that provide people with information about the voting itself.”
((NARRATOR))
The FBI is currently investigating alleged Iranian hacking attempts against the Trump and Biden-Harris campaigns.
The cybersecurity company Recorded Future also reports an increase in malign influence operations by Iran, Russia and China. They include the use of artificial intelligence to develop inauthentic articles that are then posted on fake news websites that look like mainstream media.
[[RADIO INTRO: Team lead Sean Minor via Skype]]
((Sean Minor, Recorded Future)) – ((Skype))
“To introduce bias within the content that has a political slant or a political leaning in a specific direction based on the corresponding government’s geopolitical objectives, and how those geopolitical objectives correspond to their best interests with which candidate ends up winning the election.”
((NARRATOR))
How effective are those efforts?
((Sean Minor, Recorded Future)) – ((Skype))
“At this point we have no hard data to suggest that these operations have historically actually impacted the results of the election.”
((NARRATOR))
U.S. voters are nonetheless encouraged to remain vigilant and wary of grammatical or spelling mistakes found in the articles and website domains they come across, which could give away the impersonation attempt.
((Veronica Balderas Iglesias, VOA News, Washington))
JESSICA JERREAT:
We turn to the on-going war in Ukraine where Russia has stepped up its attacks. Strikes in recent days hit a hospital among other buildings. Late in August, a strike on a hotel killed a Reuters safety adviser, and injured other journalists, who used the hotel as a base. When confronted with the evidence, Moscow tried to deny targeting civilian sites. Here’s VOA’s Polygraph fact check team with the details:
[[POLYGRAPH]]
EDITORS: PLEASE MARK EDITED WHEN DONE. POLYGRAPH WILL PRODUCE
HEADLINE: ‘He was not a journalist,’ Kremlin says about Reuters staffer killed in strike
TEASER:
PUBLISHED AT: 08/28/2024 at 12:–pm
BYLINE: William Echols
CONTRIBUTOR:
DATELINE:
VIDEOGRAPHER:
VIDEO EDITOR:
Nik Yarst
SCRIPT EDITORS: FT
VIDEO SOURCE (S): AFP, CPJ, RSF
PLATFORMS (mark with X): WEB _X_ TV __ RADIO __
TRT:
VID APPROVED BY:
TYPE:
EDITOR NOTES:))
((AFP missile attack on a hotel hosting foreign journalists in Kramatorsk WRAP))
The Kremlin neither denied nor admitted Russian responsibility for a missile attack on a hotel hosting foreign journalists in Kramatorsk, Eastern Ukraine, on August 24.
The strike killed Ryan Evans, a safety adviser for a Reuters news agency crew, and injured two Reuters journalists and other reporters.
((AFP Moscow Kremlin, Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov WRAP))
Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov downplayed the significance of the attack, arguing Russia does not target civilians and that Evans was not a journalist.
“I read information from the agency staff that he was not a journalist, but some kind of security advisor. I repeat once again: strikes are carried out on military infrastructure, or facilities in one way or another related to military infrastructure.”
That is false.
((AFP missile attack on a hotel hosting foreign journalists in Kramatorsk WRAP))
Evans was part of a Reuters news crew and had worked for the agency since 2022. He was entitled to the same protections as other media workers under international law, which also forbids directly targeting civilian objects.
Press watchdogs say Russia has a well-documented history of systematic attacks on civilian structures housing foreign journalists in Ukraine.
((Web screen shoot Reporters Without Borders (RSF) ))
Reporters Without Borders (RSF) said the Russian military hunts down journalists in Ukraine’s Russian-occupied territory, giving them a choice between “collaboration, prison or death.”
RSF has documented 53 events, in which 121 journalists have been victims, that could be classified as war crimes.
((Web screen shoot the Committee to Protect Journalists ))
Not including Evans, the Committee to Protect Journalists has documented the deaths of at least 15 journalists and media workers covering the war.
((AFP incursion into Russia’s Kursk region WRAP))
Moscow has likewise sought to control the narrative following Ukraine’s August 6 incursion into Russia’s Kursk region.
Russia has opened criminal cases against at least seven journalists who have reported from Kursk, falsely stating that they illegally crossed the border into Russia.
((AFP missile attack on a hotel hosting foreign journalists in Kramatorsk WRAP)) Ukraine’s National Union of Journalists documented Russian missile attacks on hotels in Kharkiv and other Ukrainian cities popular among journalists, calling it a deliberate tactic “to limit coverage of the war in the international media.”
JESSICA JERREAT:
Since its full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Russia, has used legislation like its foreign agent law to target critical media outlets. Now, former Soviet countries are replicating that law, in a move that worries critics. Liam Scott reports.
PLAYBOOK SLUG: TV PF Foreign Agent Laws
HEADLINE: Georgian law threatens independent reporting, critics say
TEASER:
PUBLISHED AT: 08/30/2024 at 10:40 am
BYLINE: Liam Scott
CONTRIBUTOR:
DATELINE: Washington/Prague/New York
VIDEOGRAPHER: Cristina Caicedo Smit, Krystof Maixner, Martin Bubenik, Michael Eckels
VIDEO EDITOR:
SCRIPT EDITORS: JJ, Baragona
VIDEO SOURCE (S): VOA, ZOOM, Reuters
PLATFORMS (mark with X): WEB __ TV _X_ RADIO __
TRT: 2:44
VID APPROVED BY: mas
TYPE: TVR
EDITOR NOTES: For VOA Press Freedom. Questions/review Jessica Jerreat, Liam Scott))
((INTRO))
Media rights are at risk in Georgia as the country once seen as a safe haven for journalists implements a new law. For VOA News, Liam Scott has the story.))
((NARRATION))
Tens of thousands of people took to the streets of Georgia’s capital, Tbilisi, this year to protest a new law targeting foreign-funded groups.
But to no effect. When the law goes into force in September, nonprofits and media with more than a fifth of their funding from foreign sources will be required to register as so-called foreign agents or risk inspection and hefty fines.
The law’s supporters say it will bolster transparency and Georgian sovereignty.
But analysts warn the legislation could be used to silence government critics — and push Georgia further from the West.
((For radio: Gulnoza Said is the Europe and Central Asia program coordinator at the Committee to Protect Journalists))
((Gulnoza Said, Committee to Protect Journalists)) ((Female/English))
“If they have to register, it will limit their ability to report freely and critically of the authorities. But if they don’t register, then they can be ruined financially.”
Georgia was celebrated as one of the freer former Soviet countries. But it has grown closer to Moscow in recent years, amid declining freedoms and rising corruption, according to Said.
((Gulnoza Said, Committee to Protect Journalists)) ((Female/English))
“Georgia is basically at the crossroads between Russia and the West.”
((NARRATION))
Some groups in Georgia say they will pay the fines rather than register as a foreign agent. That includes the Media Development Foundation, a press freedom group.
((For radio, Tamar Kintsurashvili is the executive director.))
((Tamar Kintsurashvili, Media Development Foundation)) ((Female/English)) ((Mandatory: Zoom))
“It’s quite [a] complicated time for independent institutions in Georgia, but it’s our fight, and we should defend our rights, and we should defend democracy in Georgia.”
((NARRATION))
Georgia is the latest in the region to adopt the Russia-style law. Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan have enacted similar laws, too.
And while the United States has its own Foreign Agents Registration Act, watchdogs say the Russian law is more expansive and used to target critics.
Moscow has designated dozens of media outlets as foreign agents. Among them, VOA and its sister network Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, known as RFE/RL.
((For radio: Stephen Capus is president of RFE/RL.))
((Stephen Capus, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty President)) ((Male/English))
“It becomes more difficult, but we’re not going to be deterred. We continue to stay on the mission.”
((NARRATION))
((For radio: Andrei Shary is director of RFE/RL’s Russian service))
((Andrei Shary, RFE/RL Russian Service Director)) ((Male/English))
“We decided to stay as long as we can, because being on the ground is crucial for us. And the pretext for leaving the country was their threat to [the] security of journalism.”
((NARRATION))
Russia’s crackdown on media after its full-scale invasion of Ukraine resulted in many journalists going into exile, including to neighboring Georgia.
((For radio: Again, Said of the Committee to Protect Journalists))
((Gulnoza Said, Committee to Protect Journalists)) ((Female/English)) \“With this legislation, Georgia may also lose that status of a safe haven for lots of critical journalists from other countries, which will be very bad.”
((NARRATION))
With parliamentary elections in October, media defenders are anxious about how the new law will affect press coverage.
((Liam Scott, VOA News))
JESSICA JERREAT:
In times of conflict or during the dozens of elections slated to take place this year, disinformation is escalating. And advances in technology –like AI –means it is harder to spot — and stop. Scammers used AI to clone the voice of one of Ghana’s best-known journalists, to endorse a product. Analysts warn the same technology could be used to spread disinformation ahead of the country’s elections in December. Senanu Tord has the story.
((PLAYBOOK SLUG: TV PF GHANA DISINFORMATION
HEADLINE: Ghana’s journalists on front line in battle against AI-generated deep fakes
TEASER:
PUBLISHED AT: 09/01/2024 at 6:49 pm
BYLINE: Senanu Tord
CONTRIBUTOR:
DATELINE: Accra, Ghana.
VIDEOGRAPHER: Senanu Tord
VIDEO EDITOR:
ASSIGNING EDITOR: JJ
SCRIPT EDITORS: JJ, cobus
VIDEO SOURCE(S): VOA Original
PLATFORMS (mark with X): WEB __ TV X RADIO X
TRT: 3:06
VID APPROVED BY: Reifenrath
TYPE: TVPKG/RADIO
EDITOR NOTES: For VOA Press Freedom. Questions/review Jessica Jerreat, Sena Tord senathefilmmaker@gmail.com ))
((INTRO)) [[Bernard Avle hosts one of the biggest morning shows in Ghana. But scammers used artificial intelligence, or AI, to clone his voice to endorse a product. Analysts warn the same technology could be used to spread disinformation ahead of Ghana’s elections in December. For VOA News, Senanu Tord reports from Accra.]]
((NARRATOR))
From the studios of Citi FM in Accra, Bernard Avle’s voice reaches tens of thousands of Ghanaians every weekday.
Along with his team, the radio and TV host engages the nation on the award-winning “Citi Breakfast Show,” ((Mandatory CG: “The Point of View” / Citi TV)) and on his TV show, “The Point of View.”
((Bernard Avle, Citi FM Journalist)) ((English/Male))
“I use a talk program, platform, to raise important developmental issues, but I also use the power of good interviews to question our duty bearers to actually demand for accountability.”
((NARRATOR))
But that voice of accountability has been hijacked.
((Bernard Avle, Citi FM Journalist)) ((Male/English))
“Somebody called me and said, ‘Bernard, I am calling to check on the sex enhancement medicine that you discussed on your TV show last week.’ And I was like ‘Woah, what are you talking about?’”
((NARRATOR))
Avle says perpetrators used artificial intelligence tools to clone his voice and show, then broadcast it on Facebook. To make it authentic, they used his show’s introduction.
((Mandatory CG: “The Point of View” / Citi TV))
[[NATS: ‘Welcome to The Point of View’]]
((NARRATOR))
But instead of talking about current affairs, the AI version promoted products. ((end courtesy))
((Bernard Avle, Citi FM Journalist)) ((Male/English))
“This is me they are using, and then a voice that sounds like mine, somehow learns how I introduce my show.”
((NARRATOR))
Computer scientist and researcher Kweku Andoh Yamoah notes a surge in deep fake cloning technologies since 2022, with tools now easily accessible.
((Kweku Andoh Yamoah, Computer Scientist))((Male/English))
“They charge you a dollar, which gives you access to clone your voice in like three steps. You repeat three phrases and then you have a cloned version of your voice saying anything.”
((NARRATOR))
In an election year, the easy access of AI poses a serious threat to Ghana’s peace and security, analysts say. During the 2020 election, fake news and misinformation led to unrest and at least eight deaths linked to political violence were recorded. Some worry that cloning technologies could make the situation worse this year.
Citi FM has already seen increased disinformation. It says perpetrators are using the media outlet’s brand and credibility to spread disinformation
((NARRATOR))
For this reason, Citi FM is introducing security features to flag fake news and cloned content in their widely circulated photos and stories. Using QR-code technology, audiences can easily verify images.
((NARRATOR))
It is also piloting a fact-checking project funded by the Danish Embassy in partnership with the Ghana Center for Democratic Development. It brings together forensic and investigative journalists.
((Emmanuel Paa Kwesi Owusu, Citi FM Head of Digital))((Male/English))
“Then we are going the step further of also getting tech involved, combating it and actually showing proof of the behind the scenes of we getting the verification of those disinformation content.”
((NARRATION))
Alongside fact-check initiatives in Ghana are calls for greater public education in media literacy and the detection of fake media in the run up to elections.
((Senanu Tord, VOA News, Accra, Ghana))
JESSICA JERREAT:
Countries including China, Russia, Iran use a range of tactics to try to influence the global stage. Beijing, for instance, sends foreign reporters to its cities to showcase culture, technology, and tourism. But often what’s missing, say analysts, is an uncensored picture of China and its human rights abuses. Victoria Amunga reports from Nairobi.
PLAYBOOK SLUG: CHINA KENYA MEDIA INFLUENCE (TVR)
HEADLINE: China uses media trips in soft power play to boost image
TEASER: Beijing sponsors media trips to China, but analysts say they don’t provide a full picture
PUBLISHED AT: 08/29/2024 at 12:29 pm
BYLINE: Victoria Amunga
CONTRIBUTOR: None
DATELINE: Nairobi
VIDEOGRAPHER: Jimmy Makhulo
VIDEO EDITOR: Jimmy Makhulo
ASSIGNING EDITOR: ELee
SCRIPT EDITORS: ELee, Baragona, Mia Bush
VIDEO SOURCE (S): VOA, Zubeidah Zoom.
PLATFORMS (mark with X): WEB __ TV _X_ RADIO _X
TRT: 2:47
VID APPROVED BY: Baragona
TYPE: TVR
EDITORS NOTE: pls include Jessica Jerreat when sending an approval copy))
((INTRO: ))
[[Beijing is sending reporters to Chinese cities to showcase culture, technology and tourism. What’s missing, say analysts, is an uncensored picture of China and its human rights abuses. Victoria Amunga for VOA News has the story.]]
((VIDEO-VOA ZUBEIDAH WORKING ON COMPUTER various PICTURES IN CHINA)) ((we need to courtesy these pics so please either Jimmy or Victoria, let us know where we see the photos and who took them))
((NARRATOR))
Kenyan veteran journalist Zubeidah Kananu still thinks about…
((Mandatory Courtesy: Zubeidah Kananu))
a trip in July that changed her world view.
((End Courtesy))
((Zubeidah Kananu, Kenyan Journalist))
“The minute you get there, you feel like you are at home away from home.”
((NARRATOR))
Kananu, a news editor and the president of Kenya’s editors’ guild, says she was among five senior journalists on a Chinese embassy-sponsored media tour.
((Zubeidah Kananu, Kenyan Journalist))
”It took us through how media has evolved in China, the new technologies that they are using, the use of AI, the use of ChatGPT in telling their stories on daily basis.”
((VIDEO-VOA ZUBEIDAH TYPING various MAO PUBLICATION))
((NARRATOR))
Kananu wrote about Mao Zedong, the founder of Communist China. Her article, published in Kenya’s local daily, is one of many stories about China she has in the pipeline. The trip gave Kananu first-hand experience interacting with people in China.
((Zubeidah Kananu, Journalist)) ((English 13 secs.))
”They’ve embraced Africa in a way that I have never seen, and they introduce you to their culture through food.”
((VIDEO – CHINESE EMBASSY))
((GRAPHIC – PENGYU STATEMENT))
((VIDEO-ZUBEIDAH JOURNALISTS TRAINING IN CHINA various))
((NARRATOR))
China sees these trips as key cultural exchanges, Chinese Embassy spokesperson Liu Pengyu tells VOA. He says, “Media cooperation can not only improve the level of the media itself, but also help deepen the political, economic, social and cultural exchanges and cooperation between countries.”
China’s efforts include sponsoring press tours to China, and even sending some journalists to Xinjiang a region where Western media have accused Beijing of human rights abuses.
((Radio: Joyce Ho is with the Human Rights Foundation.))
((Joyce Ho, Human Rights Foundation)) ((In English)) ((Female)) ((20 secs 5’48”-6’10”))
”China literally wants to, in a very dark way, take these officials and take these foreign journalists to the very exact location where these human atrocities are happening and basically, in this very censored and policed environment, tell them look around, there is nothing to be seen here.”
((VIDEO- CITIZEN TV, CHINESE TV PROGRAM))
((NARRATOR))
China has sought to boost its image abroad by developing an international media network and signing agreements with local outlets from Europe, Latin America and Africa, according to the International Federation of Journalists.
In Kenya, Beijing has set up media houses that employ hundreds of local journalists.
Chinese broadcasters are aiming to compete with Western outlets with content in local languages, including Swahili.
[[FOR RADIO: Noah Midamba is foreign policy professor at Kenya’s KCA University.]]
((Noah Midamba, KCA University)) ((English 18 secs))
”They want to do something different now. They want whatever they are investing (in) to be associated with massive information and penetration to the village level.”
((VIDEO- VOA CHINA STREETs various SGR various ZUBEIDAH various))
While Chinese-funded, large infrastructure projects have been visible examples of Beijing’s influence on the continent, hosting local journalists from around the world, say experts, is a more subtle, soft-power approach.
((Victoria Amunga, VOA News, Nairobi ))
JESSICA JERREAT:
Experts on China’s disinformation and rights record say Beijing uses these trips to try to secure positive coverage. Earlier I spoke with Yaqiu Wang, of Freedom House, about what Beijing wants out of the media tours, and what journalists should be aware of.
Thank you for being with us, Yaqiu.
Yaqiu Wang, of Freedom House:
Thank you so much for having me.
JESSICA JERREAT:
China says that this is a chance to show journalists their culture, their technology. But what is the reality of these trips? What is China not showing these journalists?
Yaqiu Wang, of Freedom House:
Well, those trips are usually very orchestrated and very restrictive. Journalists can’t go venture to talk to whoever they want. They cannot even go to another location that is not authorized by the Chinese government. So it’s very, very restricted. They can only go to places that the government send them to. They can only talk to people that the government send them to talk to. China’s become very restrictive recently with visas and with access to foreign media without having Chinese minder on one of these trips.
JESSICA JERREAT:
How easy is it? If you wanted to go and speak to an everyday person in China about what’s happened?
Yaqiu Wang, of Freedom House:
It has always been very difficult, but in recent years it’s getting really, really difficult. You know, that applies to everywhere in China. And that’s, you know, as I said, applied to everywhere in China, especially in regions like Xinjiang Tibet. It’s in Tibet, it’s just banned by law, but in Xinjiang, technically, you can still apply for a visa to get into, get into Xinjiang. Even when you actually get into Xinjiang, you’re followed everywhere. You know, journalists have sent pictures of themselves, having cars behind their own car, having people who are, you know, look suspicious, following them wherever they go. Some of the journalists, you go on them they, you know, they get to travel. They get all this access to sort of Chinese culture and new ideas presented, you know, as presented by Beijing and come back with positive stories.
JESSICA JERREAT:
How does China typically respond to foreign negative coverage?
Yaqiu Wang, of Freedom House:
Well, you know Freedom House research does show that you know people who actually went African journalists, who went to China, who does those who participate in those stores? Some did come back with a lot of positive coverage about just parenting. Chinese government Ghana generally, I think it’s the to the Chinese government advantage that, you know, they did those trips and then people foreign had positive coverage. But sometimes it doesn’t always work as they wanted, in terms of when you are actually doing critical coverage of a child of the Chinese government’s human rights abuses in China, there are a lot of repercussions, even in the country that you know the journalists live in, whether it’s by the council who denounced them, saying, you know your coverage expires, you’re smearing the Chinese image or that.
JESSICA JERREAT:
Even in the most censored countries, media and dissenting voices can play an important role as watchdog. A group of North Korean defectors in Seoul has started a news website to expose North Korean human rights abuses. And, they want to provide a more nuanced perspective about their homeland. Bill Gallo reports from the South Korean capital.
((PLAYBOOK SLUG: North Korea Defectors TVR
HEADLINE: Defectors launch site to share untold North Korea stories
TEASER: NK Insider website aims to elevate North Korean voices for global audience
PUBLISHED:
BYLINE: William Gallo
CONTRIBUTOR: Kim Hyungjin
DATELINE: Seoul, South Korea
VIDEOGRAPHER: Kim Hyungjin
PRODUCER:
SCRIPT EDITORS: Decherd, Bill Ide
VIDEO SOURCES: VOA, Zoom, AFP
PLATFORMS: WEB __ TV _X_ RADIO _X_
TRT:
VID APPROVED BY:
TYPE: TVPKG
UPDATE: ))
EDITORS: Please let Gallo screen this piece before it is released. It contains sensitive images of a defector who wants to obscure his face and voice.
((INTRO))
[[A group of North Korean defectors in Seoul has started a news website aimed at exposing North Korean human rights abuses. They also want to provide a more nuanced perspective about their homeland, as VOA’s Bill Gallo reports from the South Korean capital.]]
((VIDEO: AFP footage of Kim Jong Un overseeing recent missile launch – V000_34UA8C7 – 1ST – IMAGES – NKOREA – SKOREA – MILITARY – DRILLS – 5/31/2024))
((NARRATOR))
When North Korea appears in global newscasts, it’s usually scenes like this that dominate. The country’s leader, Kim Jong Un, overseeing a weapons test.
But those kinds of martial images obscure much of what’s really going on in the country, says North Korean defector Lee Seong-min.
((VIDEO: Lee soundbyte 1 – roughcut timecode 0:01-0:10))
((Lee Seong-min, Director, NK Insider))
((English, male voice))
“North Korea is more than nuclear weapons and Kim Jong Un. There are a lot of people with different perspectives and hopes and goals for the future of their country.”
((VIDEO: Lee/Gallo cutaways and shots of Lee showing me the website – in roughcut timecode 0:10-1:57))
Lee fled North Korea in 2012. He now helps run a website called NK Insider, whose goal is to elevate North Korean voices.
((VIDEO: Lee soundbyte 2 – roughcut timecode 4:12-4:23))
((Lee Seong-min, Director, NK Insider))
((English, male voice))
“A lot of people are talking about North Korea, scholars and experts, but there are subtle differences when you hear the voices of North Koreans who lived there in that system.”
((VIDEO: Shots of NK Insider website – roughcut timecode 1:57-4:12))
((NARRATOR))
About eight North Korean defectors write for the website, launched earlier this year. They communicate secretly with sources inside North Korea for their reporting. Some don’t want to appear on camera.
((VIDEO: Gallo listening to Zane Han, with only the back of Han’s head visible. Can also include other cutaways of Han – roughcut timecode 4:24-8:09))
Zane Han, a former Pyongyang resident, fled North Korea just two years ago.
((VIDEO: Zane Han byte – roughcut timecode 8:10-8:26))
EDITORS: PLEASE NOTE THAT ZANE’S FACE MUST BE BLURRED. ALTERNATIVELY, WE CAN USE THE CUTAWAYS OF HAN/GALLO FROM
EDITORS: PLEASE NOTE THAT WE ALSO NEED TO OBSCURE HAN’S VOICE. GALLO WILL PROVIDE DUBBED AUDIO.
((Zane Han, North Korean Defector))
((In English, male voice))
“Nobody can imagine what the situation is (like) inside North Korea, what the people experience inside North Korea – really as a slave inside North Korea. [But] I was there. I know.”
((VIDEO: More cutaways of Han – roughcut timecode 4:24-8:09))
((NARRATOR))
Han is one of very few North Koreans to recently make it to the South.
((VIDEO: AFP footage of Panmunjom joint security area at DMZ – V000_32KN462 – RAW – SKOREA – NKOREA – ARMY – JAPAN – ARMAMENT – 10/4/2022))
That’s because North Korea has tightened border security since the pandemic.
((Radio intro: “Until last month, Lee Shin-wha was South Korea’s ambassador for North Korean Human Rights))
((VIDEO: Lee Shin-wha interview – roughcut timecode 8:26-8:39))
((Mandatory Zoom credit))
((Lee Shin-wha, Former South Korean Ambassador for North Korean Human Rights))
((English, female voice))
“It’s getting more and more difficult to see new defections from North Korea. That’ s a new trend…((white flash cut))…ordinary North Korean people’s chances, I think, are almost zero.”
((VIDEO: More cutaways of Lee Seong-min – roughcut timecode 0:10-1:57))
((NARRATOR))
Lee says one of his goals is to speak for North Koreans who have no voice and cannot leave.
((VIDEO: Lee soundbyte 3 – roughcut timecode 8:39-8:47))
((Lee Seong-min, Director, NK Insider))
((English, male voice))
“To give a platform to North Korean defectors and by extension to those still living in North Korea.”
((VIDEO: More cutaways of Lee and Gallo – roughcut timecode 0:10-1:57))
((NARRATOR))
Doing what he can to provide a more nuanced perspective of his homeland.
((Bill Gallo. VOA News. Seoul, South Korea.))
JESSICA JERREAT:
That’s all for now. Thanks for watching.
For the latest news you can log on to VOA news dot com. Follow us on Instagram and Facebook at VOA News.
To get all the Press Freedom related content, follow me on X at Jessica Jerreat. Catch up on past episodes at our free streaming service, VOA Plus.
I’m Jessica Jerreat. We will see you next week, for The Inside Story.
###
